Coaxial Vs Component Speakers: Differences, Pros/Cons, And Which Is Best – Expert Guide 2023

A good set of speakers can increase your enjoyment of music in your home or car, so you can always listen to your favorite music. As a general rule, the decision is made based on what is needed, what is desirable, and how much it will cost. The question of which speaker is the best is a common one. Are coaxial speakers better than component speakers when it comes to sound quality?

Coaxial Vs. Component Speakers

It is important to understand that speakers come in a variety of forms. It is important to know what makes each type of speaker unique, and how to choose the right one whether you are selecting speakers for your computer or home theater, regardless of whether you are picking speakers for your computer or home theater. The vast majority of consumers do not want to spend a lot of money upgrading their speakers so they can enjoy the best sound quality possible, while audiophiles may opt for component speakers.

Despite the fact that component speakers provide higher quality sound, coaxial speakers are cheaper and are easier to install. Due to this, you need to choose a speaker that will be suitable for your vehicle.

In case you have any doubts about your ability to install component speakers, you may want to consider them instead. It is therefore wise for you to get a stereo system that contains at least four speakers and a subwoofer or two for your vehicle. For a truly immersive sound, why not install some component speakers and some coaxial speakers in the doors of the back seat in conjunction with a good powerful amplifier?

What are coaxial speakers?

There is a speaker system known as a coaxial car speaker which is a two-way speaker system that consists of a crossover, a tweeter, and a subwoofer joined as one unit. They can be easily installed in the same holes as older, low-quality speakers, which makes them easier to install. A single cone speaker is not only less versatile, but also more difficult to install than a speaker that uses multiple cones.

Compared to single cone speakers, coaxial speakers are generally considered as the better compromise between a cheap and poor sounding single cone speaker and a high quality, more advanced component speaker system. This type of speaker is one of the most popular in the market, since it offers good sound quality at a lower cost compared to more expensive options.

It is most common for speakers to come in two-way coaxial configurations. A mid-woofer is located almost the full circumference of the speaker, while a tweeter is located in the middle of it. As this speaker is powered by a single power source, there is only one terminal for connecting it to the power supply, as well as a woofer and tweeter system that delivers sound directly to the listener.

To connect the tweeter to the woofer in coaxial speakers, a simple capacitor crossover is used because as a result of its design, the coaxial speaker cannot produce high frequencies, so there is no crossover for the woofer. As a result, the coaxial speaker is limited in terms of performance and clarity. Coaxial speakers are superior to single-cone speakers found in factory cars in terms of sound quality and coverage across the entire range.

As well as coaxial speakers, there are three-way speakers as well, but they are not as common as two-way speakers. Speakers that are three-way coaxial, or triaxial speakers, can be distinguished by the fact that they use piezo tweeters to produce high-frequency sounds.

As a general rule, a 3-way coaxial system does not necessarily improve sound quality over a 2-way system due to the addition of an additional speaker. There are models with passive crossovers that would be better served by splitting the frequency into two rather than three, since these models have passive crossovers.

When using coaxial speakers, one of their major disadvantages is the possibility of interference between the different frequencies of the speaker, especially when using a three-way speaker.

If you are looking for a cheaper brand, this is generally more apparent, and can be a real annoyance if you were looking for crystal clear sound. If you choose high-quality speakers, then coaxial speakers can be a vast improvement over factory-installed speakers.

Coaxial speakers have some great advantages:

  • Easy sound upgrade: They can be used to replace older single cone speakers that were installed by the factory & sound bad.

  • The options for buyers in terms of quality and price are diverse – you can choose from a variety of tweeter types, crossover designs, cone materials, power ratings, and so on.

  • As a result, they give performance that is similar to that of separate 2-way component car speakers. However, you don’t have to install a separate speaker crossover, which you would have to do for a separate pair of speakers.

  • You should be able to find them in a number of places and they are very popular – in fact, they are the most popular upgrade for car speakers and they are extremely easy to find.

  • Affordability: Generally, you can find a good coaxial car speaker for around $25 or more on the market. You can find high-quality coaxials for as little as $50-$65 if you shop around.

  • In many cases, people’s older speakers have a poor frequency response that needs to be fixed immediately by incorporating coaxial speakers.

Pros & Cons

Pros
  • In order to upgrade to these speakers, all that is needed is a drop-in replacement for the old factory speakers.

  • With no effort on your part, they deliver a full range of sound.

  • A coaxial audio speaker is just as good as a component audio speaker when it comes to sound quality and reliability.

  • Low price point: It costs about $50 to purchase a pair of coaxial speakers.

Cons
  • In comparison with component speakers, this speaker offers a limited level of sound quality

  • Speakers are built-in to the device

What Are Component Speakers?

In the world of audio, component speakers are speaker systems that consist of separate speakers and a crossover that provide quality sound at a high level. The speaker offers a wider variety of sound options than a coaxial speaker, as well as being more technically sophisticated than a coaxial speaker.

The mid-range woofer, tweeter, and crossover are all independent components of the component speaker, which differs from a coaxial speaker, whose components are all incorporated together. Due to the fact that these are separate parts, you will need to install them separately as each part is separate, so you may choose to buy them individually or as a set.

It is also possible to get better dome-woofers and tweeters with component speakers, as well as better crossovers with component speakers. With these features, you will be able to customize your sound by reducing the volume of your tweeters to be able to create the perfect sound. It is also recommended that you connect your tweeters so that your system will be free of overloads in the future. With coaxial speakers, you cannot take advantage of these features.

There are more inductors and capacitors present in the speaker crossovers in component speaker sets than they do in coaxial speaker sets, which is the reason for their higher quality. In contrast to coaxial systems, these systems use two degrees of filtering, which is more efficient at removing bass and midrange frequencies while blocking high frequencies coming from the woofer.

It will result in better sound and a wider frequency range than coaxial speakers as direct coupling of the frequencies results in a direct connection between the frequencies and the intended components. You can use specific tweeters to create surround sound by putting them at various angles and locations throughout the room.

Tip: As component speakers do not have the same connectors as full range speakers, their installation may be more complicated, but if the tweeter on a component speaker is the same size, you should be able to replace that tweeter on an older speaker.

When you first install components speakers, you will need to relocate the tweeters in order to achieve the best sound quality. Due to the fact that the door speakers are situated slightly aside from the A-panels, you can create realistic three-dimensional soundscapes using them. In order to prevent excessive frequency overlap between Tweeter and Woofer, it is highly recommended that both speakers are placed within 12 inches of one another so that they do not interfere with one another.

Contrary to coaxial speakers which have a tweeter on top of the woofer, component speakers have a tweeter on top of the woofer. The fact that they are pre-assembled makes them very easy to install. As much as you may think that choosing coaxial speakers would be a better choice, but you should remember that component speakers feature an improved crossover and offer higher quality sound. It is up to you to determine how loud you want your sound to be based on your installation and what you prefer.

Component speakers offer the following advantages over coaxial speakers:

  • It is possible to achieve great sound quality with even entry-level component speaker sets due to their greater frequency response and sound accuracy overall.

  • These tweeters are usually made mostly from silk, aluminum, ceramic, or other special dome materials that are known for their rigid and high-performance design.

  • It is usually capable of handling a higher amount of power – usually 75 watts RMS, 100 watts RMS, or even more.

  • This is compared to the standard crossover slope of -6 dB/octave used on coaxial tweeters which uses a slope of -12 dB per octave, or greater.

  • A good quality crossover component is needed.

  • The terminals on speaker connectors have been improved, as have the accessories for installation.

  • This kit allows the tweeters to be mounted at a line-of-sight listening angle as well as a certain height, so that stereo imaging is as good as possible during music playback.

The fact remains, however, that the installation process for coaxial speakers can be a bit more complicated than the installation process for wireless speakers. The tweeter mounts may need to be custom-fabricated, which can result in additional costs. The crossovers must also be mounted, ideally away from moisture, and ideally relatively close to where the speakers are mounted, since they will need to be mounted as well.

There is also the fact that component speakers are quite a bit more expensive than coaxial speakers, as most component speaker sets cost about 1.5 times to several times as much as coaxial speakers.

My love for component speakers dates back a long time, and I have been using them for many years. I am confident in saying that when used properly and powered by an amplifier, it is possible to get great sound out of a set (even if it is not the most expensive model!) when used properly.

Component speaker crossovers use a better design

Comparatively, component speakers use a crossover that is designed specifically for each speaker and are made using capacitors and inductors that are of higher quality and therefore use an external crossover to control the sound. There are many benefits to using them, one of them being that they can prevent unwelcome frequencies of sound from reaching speakers that are inappropriately suited.

In the end, the result of this technology is a much higher degree of clarity and lower distortion, which allows music to be heard as it is designed to be heard.

It is even better if you can control the tweeter volume with the crossover of some component speakers. In the event that you find that the tweeter sounds too harsh to you, you may want to try this setting. Additionally, some tweeters include an overload protection circuit to ensure that they are not burned out when delivered at high power levels.


FAQ

 

Which is better coaxial or component speakers?

There are many advantages to using component speakers, but they are not only more expensive and easier to install, but they also provide better quality sound. Therefore, it is important that you select the best speakers for your car by following a few factors. Component that you have confidence in your ability to install component speakers, you should consider purchasing them.

Are component speakers better?

As far as sound quality is concerned, component speakers are superior, but full-range speakers are less expensive, easier to install, and provide a more natural sound. In most OEM systems, full-range speakers are used, making upgrading as simple as adding new speakers to the system.

Does coaxial sound better than RCA?

Coaxial Cable: A Good Cut Above the Rest

There is little difference between their audio quality and that of optical audio in terms of high-quality digital audio, and only RCA is able to stand above them due to the obvious differences between analog and digital technologies.

Do component speakers need a 4 channel amp?

The answer to this question is a resounding yes. If you want to get the most out of component speakers, you will need an amp. Your component speakers will sound better as a result of the amp’s delivery of more power to them.

What frequency should component speakers be on?

Recommended crossover frequencies

A main car speaker has a frequency range of 50-60 Hz, but the most critical part of the crossover has to be blocking the low-end bass (frequencies 80 Hz and below), a 2-way speaker has a frequency range of 3-3.5 kHz (high pass), and a midrange speaker has a frequency range of 1-3.5 kHz. There is a 3-way system: 300 Hz, 3.5 kHz, and 4.5 kHz.

Which are the best component speakers for a car?

It includes two 6.5″ 2-way component speakers from Infinity Reference that reportedly produce 270W peak and 90W RMS power.

  • You Should Consider These Premium Car Speakers if You Are Looking For A New One. The date of the meeting is March 02, 2022.

  • It is rated IP56. It is Polk Audio’s POLK DB652 DB+ 6.5-inch DB+ speaker system. …

  • There is deep bass. A Sony Xs-Fb693E 420W Wired Coaxial Woofer in Black color is available. …

  • Highs that are clear.

  • Design that is compact.

  • The sound is non-fatiguing.